England’s World Cup campaign ended in disappointment after a stoppage-time defeat in the semi-final. Lautaro Martinez headed in a Lionel Messi cross as Argentina’s relentless attacks overwhelmed a fragile backline.
The defending champions advanced to face Spain in the final, while England were left to contest the third-place play-off against France.
Former England international Joe Cole questioned the leadership of head coach Thomas Tuchel. Cole, who earned 56 caps for England, said he respects Tuchel’s managerial record but was never comfortable with a foreign coach leading the national team.
Cole argued that England should be led by an English manager, noting that outside appointments may suit smaller nations seeking development rather than a football powerhouse.
Tuchel was initially hired on a short-term deal through the summer, but the contract was extended to 2028 earlier this year. Cole believes that extension now appears to be a mistake.
According to Cole, Tuchel was brought in specifically to deliver in high-pressure tournament moments. He said the coach failed to make the decisive calls when needed most in the semi-final.
Tuchel’s tactical switch to a five-man defence, including the substitution of Anthony Gordon for Ezri Konsa, drew widespread criticism. The manager defended the changes in a post-match interview.
Tuchel said England were the better side until scoring, but Argentina shifted momentum with aggressive, high-quality play. He accepted responsibility for the substitutions.
The coach explained the back-five formation was intended to close crossing lanes against Argentina’s wide attackers and dual strikers. He acknowledged the team failed to stop runners from the second line and became too passive.
Ultimately, Tuchel said the defeat was not about structure but about a lack of physicality and intensity in critical moments. England now turn their focus to the consolation match against France.
