Elphaba's Cardigan CHAOS: Designer FIRES Back at Outrage!

Elphaba's Cardigan CHAOS: Designer FIRES Back at Outrage!

A surprising wave of discussion erupted online following the release of *Wicked For Good*, not about the dazzling gowns or intricate capes, but about a seemingly simple garment: Elphaba’s cardigan.

During a pivotal, intimate scene with Prince Fiyero, the Wicked Witch of the West appears in a grey, hole-ridden knitwear piece that quickly earned the nickname “ratty sex cardigan” from bewildered fans.

The costume, initially perceived as a misstep, was actually a deliberate choice by designer Paul Tazewell, rooted in the character’s isolated existence and resourceful nature.

For Editorial Use Only Mandatory Credit: Photo by Giles Keyte/Universal Pictures/Shutterstock (15581204p) Jonathan Bailey, Cynthia Erivo, "Wicked: For Good" (2025) "Wicked: For Good" (2025)

Tazewell explained that the cardigan, more accurately a peignoir, arose from considering what Elphaba would realistically have access to while living alone and seeking comfort and warmth.

He envisioned Elphaba as someone who crafts her own clothing, weaving garments from the elements around her, and the imperfect cardigan perfectly embodies this self-sufficiency.

The designer was surprised by questions about why Elphaba didn’t choose something more conventionally seductive, questioning where she would even acquire such an item in her secluded woodland life.

Wicked's sex scene between Ariana Grande and Jonathan Bailey was cut

This wasn’t about a lack of allure, but about authenticity; the homemade peignoir serves to define Elphaba’s character and emphasize her independent spirit.

The choice underscores the film’s commitment to staying true to the core of the story and the characters, a dedication shared by stars Cynthia Erivo and Ariana Grande.

The film, a continuation of the beloved musical phenomenon, has already captivated audiences worldwide, earning significant box office success in its first two weeks of release.

Film still from Wicked: For Good, starring Ariana Grande and Cynthia Erivo. (Picture: Giles Keyte/Universal Pictures)

Critics have lauded the performances of Erivo and Grande, recognizing their ability to bring depth and nuance to these iconic roles, solidifying the film’s place as a major cinematic event.