Allen Leech, known for his compelling portrayal of Tom Branson inDownton Abbey, now stars in a thriller that’s sparking surprisingly fierce debate. The series, originally titledToo Good To Be True, has unexpectedly climbed the Netflix charts despite a wave of critical disapproval.
The premise is deceptively simple: a single mother, Rachel, working as a cleaner, receives an offer for a better life – a job from a wealthy and enigmatic businessman. But as she delves deeper into his world, a chilling suspicion begins to grow, questioning his true intentions and the price of her newfound opportunity.
However, the show hasn’t resonated with everyone. Critics have been unforgiving, withRotten Tomatoesgiving it a dismal 22% audience score. Viewers have described the plot as “predictable” and “utterly boring,” lamenting a lack of twists and uninspired acting.
Yet, a curious phenomenon is unfolding. Despite the harsh reviews, a dedicated audience is finding something to appreciate. Some viewers claim it’s “better than expected,” captivated by the complex dynamic between the mother, her son, and her closest friend.
One viewer noted the series was surprisingly “watchable,” while another praised the endearing interplay between the central characters. This division highlights a fascinating truth about taste – sometimes, a show can resonate on a personal level even when it fails to impress critics.
The show isn’t alone in defying expectations. Even the widely-pannedEmily in Parishas reached the number one spot in Netflix charts across 75 countries, proving that popularity doesn’t always align with critical acclaim.
Currently, Harlan Coben’sRun Awayholds the top spot on Netflix, boasting a much healthier 81% score onRotten Tomatoes. But for those seeking a thriller with a controversial edge,Captivated– as it’s now known on Netflix – offers a compelling, if divisive, viewing experience.
The series presents a stark question: can a gripping story overcome flawed execution? And more importantly, is it worth discovering for yourself?
