A storm of controversy erupted on Saturday after former professional goalkeeper Shay Given used shockingly inappropriate language during a live broadcast on BBC’s Final Score.
While discussing the brief and unsuccessful tenure of Wilfried Nancy as Celtic manager, Given described Nancy’s time at the club as “an absolute Holocaust.” The comment came during a discussion about Celtic’s recent struggles, particularly a damaging defeat against Rangers.
The host, Jason Mohammad, immediately steered the conversation away from Given’s remark, and later issued an on-air apology for the offensive language. The incident quickly ignited outrage across social media platforms.
Given himself swiftly responded with a public apology, stating he was unaware of the full and horrific meaning of the word “Holocaust,” which refers to the systematic genocide of six million Jews during World War II. He expressed genuine remorse for the pain his words caused.
Acknowledging his lack of understanding, Given pledged to educate himself further and announced a donation of his broadcast fee to the Holocaust Educational Trust. He emphasized his commitment to learning from this deeply regrettable error.
The incident casts a shadow over Given’s burgeoning career as a football pundit, having transitioned to broadcasting after a distinguished playing career that included 134 appearances for the Republic of Ireland and spells with prominent clubs like Newcastle and Manchester City.
The fallout from Given’s statement highlights the critical importance of language and the devastating impact of trivializing historical tragedies. It serves as a stark reminder of the need for sensitivity and awareness when discussing sensitive topics in the public sphere.
The BBC has yet to comment further on the situation, but the incident has undoubtedly prompted internal discussions regarding editorial standards and the responsibility of its on-air personalities.
