The incoming mayor of New York City, Zohran Mamdani, revealed a personal apology from NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch following a deeply unsettling incident at a Manhattan charity dinner. Her brother, Benjamin Tisch, a prominent billionaire, publicly labeled Mamdani an “enemy” of the Jewish people, creating a tense and jarring moment for those present.
The remarks, delivered at the Met Council’s annual gala, reportedly stunned the room into silence. Witnesses described a palpable shock as Benjamin Tisch, CEO of Loews Corporation, voiced his accusation, particularly given the commissioner’s recent agreement to continue serving under Mamdani’s leadership.
Mamdani addressed the situation at a community meeting, acknowledging the apology received by his team. He firmly stated his commitment to serving all New Yorkers, emphasizing inclusivity and a dedication to representing the interests of every community, including Jewish New Yorkers.
Despite the inflammatory comments, Mamdani expressed his intention to maintain a working relationship with Commissioner Tisch. He underscored his focus on public safety and justice for all five boroughs, positioning the apology as a step towards a productive partnership despite existing policy differences.
An NYPD spokesperson relayed Commissioner Tisch’s message, expressing understanding of the fear within the Jewish community and reaffirming her belief in Mamdani’s commitment to representing all New Yorkers. This statement aimed to quell concerns and signal a path forward.
The incident is further complicated by the fact that members of the Tisch family previously contributed over $1 million to political action committees actively opposing Mamdani’s mayoral campaign and supporting a rival candidate. This financial backing adds another layer to the already charged atmosphere.
Mamdani, a democratic socialist known for his critical stance on Israeli policy, has consistently refuted accusations of antisemitism. He maintains that his views are distinct from prejudice against Jewish people and are rooted in political disagreement.
Prior to this recent flare-up, Mamdani openly acknowledged disagreements with Commissioner Tisch, but expressed optimism about their ability to collaborate effectively. He characterized these differences as a sign of a healthy partnership, capable of navigating complex challenges.
The controversy unfolds just weeks before Mamdani’s inauguration, casting a shadow over the transition period. The incident highlights the delicate balance between political discourse, personal beliefs, and the responsibility of public officials to foster unity and understanding.
The situation underscores the deep divisions within the city and the challenges Mamdani will face as he attempts to unite a diverse population and deliver on his promises of safety and justice for all.
