TOBY CARVERY DESTROYS CENTURIES-OLD TREE: NOW THEY FACE THE AXE!

TOBY CARVERY DESTROYS CENTURIES-OLD TREE: NOW THEY FACE THE AXE!

A centuries-old oak, a silent witness to history, now lies felled in north London, sparking outrage and a legal battle. The tree, estimated to be between 450 and 500 years old, stood for generations before its sudden removal last April.

The owner of a nearby establishment authorized the felling, claiming expert advice indicated the tree was dying and posed a public safety risk. However, this explanation has done little to quell the fury of environmentalists and local residents who cherished the ancient landmark.

The loss is particularly acute because the oak provided a vital habitat for a range of wildlife, including rare and endangered species of beetles dependent on decaying wood. Its destruction has drawn comparisons to the infamous felling of the Sycamore Gap tree, a beloved icon felled in Northumberland.

The sad remains of the enormous, ancient oak tree on the SW edge of the Whitewebbs Toby Carvery car park which was ?inexplicably (and potentially illegally) felled by unknown contractors last week. Enfield Council's tree officer is investigating; at present the council is treating the loss as criminal damage and the matter has been referred to the police. The notices taped to the stump relate to a belated Tree Preservation Order to prevent any further work taking place at the site without council consent. What a special tree it was, and what a loss to the ecology and heritage of Whitewebbs Park

Despite an initial investigation by the Metropolitan Police finding no evidence of criminal activity, the local council is pursuing a far more significant consequence: eviction. They allege “serious breaches” of the lease agreement governing the property.

The council served an eviction notice in October and has initiated proceedings in Edmonton County Court, seeking to forfeit the lease entirely. A full trial is anticipated later this year or in early 2027, promising a public airing of the contentious details.

Deputy Leader of the council, Tim Leaver, described the tree’s destruction as a “reckless act” that caused “huge damage” and dramatically shortened its natural lifespan. He emphasized the tree, sometimes called the Guy Fawkes Oak, was an “irreplaceable part of Enfield’s natural heritage.”

LONDON, ENGLAND - APRIL 17: A pedunculate oak, 'Quercus robur', known locally as the 'Guy Fawkes Oak' is cordoned off after being felled on April 17, 2025 on the edge of Whitewebbs Park in the Enfield area of London, England. The owners of an adjacent restaurant, Toby Carvery, said they had the 450-year-old tree felled due to safety concerns. The local council disputes that the tree, which sits on land leased to Toby Carvery by the council, needed to be felled and has threatened legal action over the matter. (Photo by Dan Kitwood/Getty Images)

The council asserts the owner failed to meaningfully engage in discussions or offer any form of restitution for the loss. They are now demanding a public apology and substantial financial reparations to address the “irreversible damage” inflicted upon the community and the environment.

The council’s stance is firm: accountability is paramount. This case, they argue, is about defending the environment and preserving the shared heritage of Enfield for future generations. It’s a stand against what they perceive as a disregard for natural treasures.

Following the felling, the company’s chief executive issued an apology, stating they had “acted in good faith.” However, this expression of regret has been met with skepticism, failing to appease those who mourn the loss of the ancient oak.

The felled tree stands as a stark reminder of the fragility of our natural world and the enduring value of ancient landscapes. The legal battle unfolding promises to be a defining moment in the ongoing struggle to balance development with environmental preservation.