A confrontation in St. Augustine, Florida, has ignited a fierce debate over free speech and equal justice. Conservative journalist Kaitlin Bennett found herself facing a federal charge after simply asking questions of Democrats in a public space.
The incident began during routine on-the-street interviews, a cornerstone of journalistic practice protected by the First Amendment. Bennett alleges federal agents singled her out, issuing a citation for what she describes as inconvenient political speech.
This wasn’t a simple ticket. Bennett explained the citation, delivered by a federal agent, carries the weight of a criminal record if paid. She is now fighting the charge with legal representation, determined to challenge what she calls a “bogus” accusation.
Viral video footage captures the tense exchange with a National Park Service ranger. Despite acknowledging Bennett was on public property, the ranger demanded she relocate to a designated “First Amendment area” – requiring a permit for speech in a public forum.
When Bennett invoked her rights as a member of the media, the ranger dismissed her claims, labeling her a “counter-protester.” The situation escalated, with the ranger even appearing to mock her, suggesting she was simply creating “more content.”
The result was a federal ticket for “disobeying a lawful order,” totaling a hefty $580 in fines and forfeitures. When pressed for specifics on the order Bennett allegedly disobeyed, the ranger reportedly offered no clear explanation.
The case has drawn attention to what some perceive as a stark double standard in the application of justice. Critics point to the contrasting treatment of left-wing activists who disrupt public gatherings with little to no consequence.
Just days before Bennett’s encounter, disgraced former CNN host Don Lemon was filmed participating in a disruptive protest at Cities Church in St. Paul, Minnesota. A group stormed a Sunday service, harassing congregants and leveling accusations against the pastor.
The protesters, including Lemon, actively disrupted worship and targeted parishioners, including children, with accusations related to immigration enforcement. This incident, unlike Bennett’s, has not resulted in any reported charges or fines.
The disparity in these cases raises serious questions about selective enforcement and the potential chilling effect on free speech for those with dissenting viewpoints. It fuels concerns about a growing two-tiered system of justice within the United States.
