CHURCH'S DARK SECRET UNLEASHED! Couple's Renovation Nightmare Revealed.

CHURCH'S DARK SECRET UNLEASHED! Couple's Renovation Nightmare Revealed.

Lucy and Rhys Thomas envisioned a unique family home – a transformation of a centuries-old church. Little did they know, their renovation project would unearth a secret hidden for generations, a poignant connection to the past that would forever alter their plans.

They secured the 900-year-old church at auction, captivated by its weathered stones and silent history. A whisper of potential burials beneath the floor had been mentioned, a mere five or six individuals, they were told – a manageable historical footnote. The reality, however, proved dramatically different.

The initial stage of the renovation involved carefully removing the floor. Beneath a thin layer of earth, the first remains appeared. Then another, and another, until it became clear this wasn’t a handful of interments, but a vast, forgotten cemetery. Ultimately, they discovered the resting places of eighty-three individuals.

Lucy and Rhys Thomas.

An archaeologist was immediately brought in, confirming the historical practice of burying prominent community members within the church walls. The couple faced a profound decision: disturb these long-held remains, or adapt their vision to honor them. They chose respect.

Instead of relocation, they decided to preserve the site, carefully building around the skeletal remains. Husbands lay beside wives, parents with their children – families reunited in eternity. A sense of solemn responsibility settled over the project, transforming it from a renovation into a delicate act of preservation.

The church, founded in 1142, had remained largely untouched for decades. The couple initially believed they were purchasing a five-bedroom house, a surprising discovery that added another layer of complexity to their undertaking. The first eighteen months were spent navigating paperwork and patiently awaiting approvals.

Lucy Thomas at St Peters Church, Peterstone Wentlooge, Wales, which was founded in 1142. // A couple renovating a church into a dream home found 83 bodies buried underneath - and covered them with underfloor heating. Lucy, 53, and Rhys Thomas, 45, regularly drove past the Grade I listed St Peters Church - then saw it was for sale. The listing said it was a five bedroom house and they assumed the work had already been done at the 900-year-old religious building. But at the viewing, they were stunned to find it was still a church and needed a complete overhaul - but bought it at auction for ?405,000. They were warned there might be 'five or six' bodies under the floor as historically, influential or rich people were buried inside a church. Lucy and Rhys were left 'shocked' when they dug up the flooring and 'body after body' appeared - a total of 83. Mum-of-five Lucy says that out of respect for the dead they decided to leave the bodies there - and then re-laid a new floor on top of them "along with underfloor heating''. Photo released 23/01/2026

The renovation itself was a steep learning curve. Rhys admitted to countless hours spent researching online and connecting with others undertaking similar listed building projects. They embraced the challenge, determined to breathe new life into the ancient structure.

Original features were meticulously preserved. The engraved stones of the original floor, carefully removed, now form a beautiful patio. A soaring ceiling demanded a creative solution, leading to the construction of a stunning mezzanine level, expertly crafted by builders they readily admitted they needed.

The church altar now graces one of the bedrooms, a striking reminder of the building’s original purpose. The historic tower and its eight bells were lovingly restored, their resonant chimes once again echoing through the valley.

St Peters Church, Peterstone Wentlooge, Wales, which was founded in 1142.

Modern comforts were seamlessly integrated – double-glazed windows, underfloor heating, a snooker table, a bar, and even a hot tub. The result is a breathtaking blend of history and contemporary living, a testament to their dedication and respect for the past.

Now, others have the opportunity to experience the magic of this unique home. The church is occasionally opened to guests, offering a glimpse into a remarkable transformation and a poignant connection to those who came before.