AGENT'S BLUNDER: Did ICE Fire the Shot That Killed Him?

AGENT'S BLUNDER: Did ICE Fire the Shot That Killed Him?

The final moments of Alex Pretti, a 37-year-old ICU nurse, are shrouded in a chilling mystery. Shot and killed by federal immigration agents in Minneapolis, the circumstances surrounding his death are now under intense scrutiny, raising disturbing questions about a potential tragic mistake.

Pretti was legally carrying a concealed handgun while observing and filming the ICE agents, a right protected under Minnesota law. Video footage shows officers approaching him, disarming him, and then, moments later, unleashing a barrage of ten shots. Initial reports suggested he was “armed,” but a horrifying possibility has emerged: the agents may have inadvertently fired his own weapon.

As one agent retreated with Pretti’s confiscated pistol, the gun appears to discharge in the video. This single shot may have triggered a cascade of reactions, “spooking” other agents and leading them to open fire on an already disarmed man. The possibility of a “negligent discharge” is now at the center of the investigation.

The moment that the firearm of a man identified as Alex Pretti is retrieved from a waistband holster by a federal officer (in light grey jacket, crouched) as another officer (in green) draws his weapon, before Pretti was fatally shot in Minneapolis, Minnesota, U.S., January 24, 2026 is seen in a still image of a video obtained by Reuters. VIDEO OBTAINED BY REUTERS/via REUTERS THIS IMAGE HAS BEEN SUPPLIED BY A THIRD PARTY. NO RESALES. NO ARCHIVES. AN UNCROPPED AND UNPROCESSED VERSION HAS BEEN PROVIDED SEPARATELY. VERIFICATION LINES: Reuters was able to verify the location and date of the videos from original file metadata. Buildings, road layout, trees and utility poles which matched file and satellite imagery of the place. The Department of Homeland Security said one of his agents fired shots in Minneapolis, Minnesota on Saturday (January 24). Minnesota Governor Tim Walz confirmed a shooting by federal agents took place on Saturday (January 24).

Rob Doar, President of the Minnesota Gun Owners Law Centre, believes the initial shot was accidental, fired by an agent handling the disarmed weapon. His analysis of the video aligns with a documented phenomenon known as “contagious fire,” where the sound of gunfire dramatically increases the likelihood of other officers discharging their weapons, even mistakenly.

The shooting has ignited outrage in Minnesota, fueling demands to remove ICE from the city. The response from national figures has been starkly divided. While protests swell, former President Trump has defended the agents’ actions, even suggesting the potential invocation of the Insurrection Act to quell unrest.

The Insurrection Act, a historical law dating back to 1807, grants the President the power to deploy the military to suppress civil disorder. It was last used during the 1992 Los Angeles riots following the acquittal of officers in the Rodney King beating. Trump has previously stated his willingness to utilize the act if faced with obstruction from local authorities.

A screengrab from a video obtained by Reuters shows a law enforcement officer pinning down a man identified as Alex Pretti, before he was fatally shot when federal agents were trying to detain him in Minneapolis, Minnesota, U.S., January 24, 2026. VIDEO OBTAINED BY REUTERS/via REUTERS THIS IMAGE HAS BEEN SUPPLIED BY A THIRD PARTY. NO RESALES. NO ARCHIVES. AN UNCROPPED AND UNPROCESSED VERSION HAS BEEN PROVIDED SEPARATELY. VERIFICATION LINES: Reuters was able to verify the location and date of the videos from original file metadata. Buildings, road layout, trees and utility poles which matched file and satellite imagery of the place. The Department of Homeland Security said one of his agents fired shots in Minneapolis, Minnesota on Saturday (January 24). Minnesota Governor Tim Walz confirmed a shooting by federal agents took place on Saturday (January 24).

Adding to the controversy, Trump’s former Secretary of Homeland Security labeled Pretti a “domestic terrorist,” and a Border Patrol Commander alleged he was planning an attack on law enforcement. These claims, however, are directly contradicted by video evidence and eyewitness accounts, which confirm Pretti never brandished his weapon.

Alex Pretti’s family vehemently refutes the accusations leveled against their son, calling them “sickening lies.” They emphasize his compassionate nature and his dedication to protesting what he perceived as injustices, specifically the separation of families and the treatment of immigrants. His father shared that Alex participated in protests because he “cared” about people and believed in doing what was right.

The family’s plea for truth resonates amidst the escalating tensions. They point to the video evidence, showing Alex with his phone in one hand and his other hand raised in a defensive gesture, attempting to protect a woman who had been pushed to the ground. The question now is not just how Alex Pretti died, but why, and whether a tragic mistake was compounded by hasty judgment and inflammatory rhetoric.