Sheriff Jim Cooper criticized California's mental health diversion system, warning that expanding its scope could dilute the initiative voters overwhelmingly approved.
He argued that broadening diversion eligibility for theft offenses would undermine accountability and weaken the program’s impact.
Governor Newsom’s office countered by emphasizing crime trend data and the success of existing diversion initiatives.
The governor cited recent legislation tightening oversight of the diversion program, noting bipartisan support for the reforms.
Cooper acknowledged that new guardrails had been added but maintained they are insufficient to address the system’s shortcomings.
He stressed that certain offenses, including felony child abuse and crimes by sexually violent predators, should not qualify for diversion.
Cooper also criticized California's domestic violence statutes, stating many felony offenses remain classified as non‑violent.
He highlighted the daily prevalence of domestic violence across all communities, emphasizing the need for serious treatment and accountability.
When questioned about lawmakers’ opposition to reclassifying domestic violence as a violent felony, Cooper said they simply vote against it.
His broader critique targets the state’s criminal justice policies, arguing that current laws undercut victim protection and public safety.
Cooper has repeatedly opposed Proposition 36, claiming legislators focus on diversion for retail theft instead of fully funding the initiative.
He noted that Californians voted for Proposition 36 in all counties to address retail theft, yet new diversion proposals threaten its goals.
The sheriff also condemned youth offender and elderly parole policies, arguing they prioritize age over crime severity.
After a fatal shooting involving an 18‑year‑old, Cooper warned that California law often favors early release for young offenders.
He argued that parole laws create a system that limits detention but ignores the harm inflicted on victims.
Cooper criticized the compassionate release program after a former attempted cop killer was released early and later re‑arrested.
He accused lawmakers of overlooking prosecutorial and law‑enforcement warnings about expanding release standards, claiming ideology outweighs safety.
Concluding his remarks, Cooper urged a return to prioritizing victims in the justice system.
