A disturbing scene unfolded in Toronto this past weekend, escalating far beyond typical protest rhetoric. Officers found themselves targeted with a barrage of repulsive projectiles – used toilet paper, eggs, and plastic bags filled with what appeared to be urine. The alleged attacks occurred during a demonstration at City Hall, a clash between the Canada First “Stop Mass Immigration Rally” and a determined counter-protest.
The counter-protest, comprised of individuals identifying with Antifa, local unions, and those regularly participating in pro-Palestinian demonstrations, sought to disrupt the Canada First gathering. But the tactics employed took a shocking turn, marking a new level of hostility in Toronto’s protest landscape. Police reported that this was the first instance of loaded projectiles being thrown, prompting swift and decisive action.
Eight arrests were made, with allegations of assault against three police officers. The atmosphere was described as “volatile” and “disgusting” by Toronto Police Association president Clayton Campbell, who detailed the unsettling experience of his members being pelted while attempting to maintain order. A smoke bomb was also thrown directly towards the officers, adding to the chaos.
Videos circulating on social media paint a picture of a near-riot, with police struggling to contain the escalating tensions. Sources indicate that the most disruptive behavior originated from the counter-protesters attempting to breach the line surrounding the Canada First demonstration. The scene was described as “hectic,” with officers making arrests and utilizing bicycles as barriers.
The temperature of the demonstration was noticeably higher than previous events since October 7th, 2023. Canada First founder Joe Anidjar, in a speech delivered on Nathan Phillips Square, voiced a sentiment that ignited further anger, stating that those who cannot respect Canada’s way of life should “go back home.”
This statement drew immediate criticism from Toronto Councillor Neethan Shan, who condemned the “xenophobia” and “anti-immigrant sentiments” being deliberately spread to foster fear and racism. Anidjar countered, asserting that the demonstration represented a diverse group of individuals united in their desire to preserve Canadian culture and identity.
While freedom of speech allows for the expression of differing viewpoints, the line was crossed when violence erupted. Police emphasized that peaceful protest is a right, but the throwing of objects at officers and others is unacceptable. Fortunately, law enforcement was able to prevent the situation from spiraling further out of control.
Despite accusations of bias, police managed to keep the opposing groups largely separated, allowing Canada First to complete their demonstration. Lawyer and journalist Caryma Sa’d noted that while the situation remained relatively organized on Nathan Phillips Square, it deteriorated when the groups moved to Bay Street.
One officer was reportedly punched during the melee, and a total of 29 charges were laid, including assault on a police officer. The Toronto Police Association expressed pride in their members’ handling of the situation, vowing to continue supporting them in the face of such challenges. They will continue to facilitate lawful demonstrations, but violence will not be tolerated.
The events of Saturday underscore the delicate balance police face when managing protests. Too little intervention invites criticism, while excessive force draws scrutiny. In this instance, they appeared to strike a necessary balance, maintaining order while upholding the right to peaceful assembly. Anidjar has hinted at future demonstrations, suggesting this may not be the last time these groups clash.
The incident serves as a stark reminder of the potential for protests to devolve into chaos and the importance of maintaining a commitment to peaceful expression, even in the face of deeply held disagreements.
